Welcome to Pohl Vault, a collection of reflections on being a middle school language arts & social studies teacher.
Showing posts with label technology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label technology. Show all posts

September 17, 2016

Anecdotal Notes: Still crazy after all these years!

Anecdotal notes-- AAAARGH! You would think that after 30 years of teaching, I would have this beast figured out! I want to capture the important stuff about kids as it happens, but I don't want to spend a lot of time doing it. I also need my system to be organized and easy to use. I want to track data about individuals as well as easily identify small groups with similar needs. Is there one system that can do it all?

I've tried the notebook approach: Each student gets a page in a notebook, and I take notes on that page when I confer or get a new piece of data (like a standardized test score or a reading goal) or have a parent conference. That works pretty well if I'm only going to focus on the individual and his/her progress. It's much harder to see trends across the class or pull together small groups.

I've tried an iPad app called Confer. It seemed like it could hold individual info as well as do the kind of sorting/grouping I was looking for. It also promised a way to match student information with the CCSS standards to track progress and help with standards-based grading. However, the set up took so long, inputting the CCSS and students, and typing on the iPad is so slow for me, that I abandoned that method as well.

For several years I used a card system that was housed in a folder. Each student had a card, but unlike the notebook idea, the cards were taped onto the interior sides of the folder in a tiered manner, so that one overlapped the other, leaving a small portion visible at the bottom. Student names were written on the visible part, and I could use that space to track how often I met with a student. Again, this was good for individual progress, and a better system for making sure I was getting to all students in a timely manner, but still not so good at pulling together groups of common needs. Also, handwriting is slow work!

So this year I am back to technology. Our tech coach suggested using Google Forms as a system. It's not slick and it's not fancy, but so far it's working out. I have a form that lists student names as a "checklist" of answers to "question", a list of my unit names as the checklist answers to my next "question", an open text box to answer the question of Notes, and a final open text box for the question of Items for Next Meeting. As I confer or get data, I select a student name and unit from the checkboxes, quickly type in my conference notes, and capture what next steps will be. This data, along with the date, is gathered in Responses, which can be viewed as a Google spreadsheet.

The advantage of the spreadsheet is in the sorting and filtering it can do that the notebook and flip cards can't. If I want to see all notes on a student, I can sort names alphabetically, and all responses for the student are clustered together.

If I want to see which students need work on their close reading, for example, I can filter out only the Short Story Reading unit, and even find all responses that have the words "close reading" in them. Voila! A small group with similar needs!

So far I don't have many notes on kids because we are just getting started in school. I wonder if the spreadsheet will eventually get messy or bulky and hard to use. I may need to have one for semester 1 and one for semester 2. However, it has fulfilled a lot of needs so far.

Another tech tool suggested by the tech coach was Evernote. I haven't done much exploring with it yet because I'm kind-of into Google Forms right now. So I'm keeping that option in my back pocket as I see how Forms plays out.

What is your anecdotal note systems? Does yours handle multiple classes and large numbers of kids? Can you track individuals as well as filter/sort for small groups?

September 3, 2016

U.S. Elections Projects: "Fair and Balanced"

As a teacher of U.S. History, I cannot ignore the momentous happening of a Presidential election, even though I am teaching in a Middle Eastern country to international students. Our kids walked into the new school year from summer vacation with their heads filled with news, ads, and dinner table conversations about the candidates. Passions were high, and misinformation rampant. 

My grade 8 colleague and I knew we needed to harness the energy around this topic without letting it devolve into a "my candidate is better than yours" playground fight. We needed to find a project which allowed students to learn about the candidates and issues in an objective manner so that they could make informed choices rather than being swayed by the latest sensational headline or the loudest voice. We needed a way for students to agree or disagree with a position and back up that opinion with factual information, rather than fighting for (or against) a particular candidate. Just like our professional meeting norms, we wanted them to "disagree with ideas, not people" to keep things from getting too personal.

CC image from Wikimedia Commons website
We decided against doing a traditional campaign ad project. First, the vast majority of our students already backed one candidate, which makes those that favor the other major candidate feel outnumbered and isolated-- never a good idea in middle school. Secondly, if we "assigned" a candidate to students as a way to get a more balanced view, those students who had very strong feelings against that candidate would instantly shut down-- again, never a good idea to lose motivation with middle schoolers.

By G. Skidmore on Wikipedia
Therefore, we decided to make our project revolve around issues, and to include the top four candidates instead of only the top two: Jill Stein (Green Party), Gary Johnson (Libertarian Party), Donald Trump (Republican Party), and Hillary Clinton (Democratic Party). We formed groups of 4, and students split the candidates between themselves. We then randomly assigned the groups one issue each: Immigration, Economy, Terrorism, Civil Rights, Environment, and Gun Control. 
Image from Wikipedia website

Students researched "their" candidate's position on how to solve the focal issue. They used ProCon.org (they have a very easy-to-use 2016 Presidential Elections page that features all four candidates), the candidates' own websites, and reputable news organizations to find their information. Students did not have to agree with the candidates' positions; they merely had to find out what that position was so that they could teach their group members about it. This alleviated a lot of push-back when students had to research a candidate who was not their initial choice. They could see the logic of understanding other candidates' views in order to argue intelligently against them.

Once the research was finished, students shared out how each of the four candidates would solve that particular issue. Next, they had to come to an agreement about which position their group would support, answering this question: Which solution is best for America? This led to some very lively discussions, with lots of critical thinking around the pros and cons of each, and students defending their opinions with researched information. Some groups also learned the art of compromise when they could not agree on a single position.

By focusing the discussion on the candidates' positions on a particular issue, it kept candidates' personalities out of it (the source of much of the sensationalist news headlines). Additionally, the focus was so narrow that it avoided the question of who is the best candidate overall. It also allowed those few students who backed the less popular candidate a safe way to advocate for their candidate without getting shouted down. 

The final step was to present their findings in a multimedia project ("live" slideshow, screen-cast recording, or movie) during which the group's choice for best solution was highlighted and contrasted with the other solutions. All students were involved in creating the production, since each group member was an "expert" on one position. Interestingly, when all the presentations were finished, each class featured three different candidates as having a "best" position, and across all classes, all four candidates were represented at least once. 

When I asked students what they had learned from this project, many students wrote that they didn't know there were other parties besides the Democratic and Republican parties. They had never heard of Gary Johnson, Jill Stein, or their parties. They learned that their preferred candidate may not have had the best solution to their focal issue, and that other candidates had some good points. They learned that some candidates agreed with others on issues-- even Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton had points of agreement! They learned about the particulars involved in their focal issue, and some of the terms that were being thrown around related to them: TPP, fracking, immigrants vs. refugees, Dreamers, Obamacare, Religious Restoration Act, EPA, etc. They also learned that there are places to find accurate information, and to not always believe what a candidate or headline says is true.

We still have a couple months before the elections. Although our project is over, our discussions aren't. We will jump into early US history next week, but as the Presidential debates and other major milestones happen, we will keep track of current events. My hope is that, as the months pass, my students will listen and read with a more critical and informed perspective than they had when the year began. They will be active citizens.

January 2, 2016

Considering the Connotations of Word Choice in Media

CC photo by J. Pohl

My family just returned from a winter break trip to Vietnam. One of our first stops was the War Remnants Museum in Ho Chi Minh City. It's called "War Remnants" because it is filled with the flotsam and jetsam the American military left behind when they retreated, including tanks, helicopters, boats, bombs, shells, and the long-term effects from Agent Orange. The big vehicles fill the outdoor courtyard, while inside the Museum building photographs document the horrors of war. It was very disturbing.
CC photo by J. Pohl

But I'm writing about it here on my blog because it was fascinating to view a world event from the opposite perspective from the one I grew up with. I was a child when the Vietnam War was happening, so it was background noise in my happy-go-lucky existence. I have vague memories, reinforced by movie images no doubt, of soldiers in muddy tropical jungles, of drawing the line between the "good guys" (South Vietnamese) and the "bad guys" (North Vietnamese), and of feeling sad for those families who lost a son to the war. The Museum had American journalists' articles and photographs displayed, with headlines like, "Terrorists captured..." accompanying an image of a small shirtless man with his hands tied behind his back being guided into an open jeep. In my memories, Americans were helping the good guys to defend their country from the bad guys and our soldiers were "heroes", but despite our noble aspirations, we "lost" the war.

photo by peregringo.com
In Vietnam, I heard the war called "The American War," a title that jarred me a little (all "our" wars are named for other places: Iraq War, the War in Afghanistan, the Korean War). At the Museum, I read signs that called the Americans "the Imperialists" who fought against the "will of the people". The Vietnamese soldiers were "martyrs". An international war crimes committee declared that the U.S. had committed "genocide" against the Vietnamese people. 

Wow, that was so totally different than what I had been fed as a child.

It made me think about the power of words, the connotations behind the words we hear in the media and how they can so strongly spin an event to be one way or another. The "terrorist" the Americans captured was the "martyr" to the Vietnamese cause. Of course I know that governments and media show bias through their word choice, but it takes a certain amount of cognitive effort to stop and analyze that bias. How often do our students make that effort? Probably close to never.

As we move into the second semester and closer to the U.S. Presidential elections, it seems ever more urgent to teach students to notice bias-laden language in the media. The CCSS includes reading and language standards (R8.4, L8.5, H/SS6-8.6) that specifically address understanding the connotative meanings of words and how they affect meaning. It will mean drawing students' attention to word choice options, the subtleties of meaning behind synonyms, and considering the perspectives of the author and audience. 

Pretty abstract stuff. I'm hoping that with consistent practice, students will begin to internalize this process so that they take their critical lens to any reading or viewing, so that they don't just take things like "good guys" and "bad guys" to heart without considering the spin behind it.

December 19, 2015

In the Technology Groove with Google

I am totally in the technology groove these days. I love it when technology tools exactly fit the learning need, and especially when one tool just keeps on giving. This has been my experience lately with Google Classroom, Google Documents, and Lucidcharts.


I'm loving Google Classroom. I set up an assignment, I attach documents, and I give each student a copy of the Google doc to use which is already named and put into a folder for the student and me. No longer are Google docs "lost" because they didn't get placed into a folder. No longer do I get shared on 23 "Untitled Documents" or "Fantasy Story" documents without knowing who it belongs to. No longer do I send out a group email with attachments. Everything is organized and right at everyone's fingertips.

Google Docs is my best friend when it comes to formative feedback. For some reason, giving feedback to 46 documents feels much easier than facing a towering stack of 46 paper notebooks. Maybe it's the sheer weight, or the challenge of bad handwriting, or the difficulty of transporting all those bulky notebooks home that make them feel so intimidating. Maybe it's knowing that I have to take the notebooks away from the students to grade them (not quickly), which means they can't use them in the meantime, that feels bad. Google Docs fixes all those problems. I can dip in and out of the documents several times over the course of the unit, looking at draft work, making suggestions, staying on top of who is completing things on time and who is not, lifting everyone's level without taking their tool away from them to do it. 

image from commons.wikimedia.com
My new friend is Lucidcharts. I first asked students to use them in the fantasy reading unit as a way to track ideas across a longer text: character development, character interactions, setting and plot events, how elements interact. I had some kids who took off with this, adding shapes, color and keys to make everything connect:

When we moved from fantasy reading to fantasy writing, and we got to the planning stage, I casually suggested, "You know, a Lucidchart could be a good tool for this work. Or you can use paper, or make a timeline in your notebook document. But whatever way you do it, please make sure you get it into your notebook so I can see it and give you feedback." Many kids loved the Lucidchart idea and eagerly jumped in and even figured out on their own how to embed the chart into the notebook instead of adding a link. Here's one that sort-of blew me away:

I have to give credit here to our fantastic tech integrator who regularly checks in with us and asks, "So what are you guys working on? Are you interested in adding a little tech to that? Here, let me show you this tool..." All of these ideas came from her. I am not a huge techie, but I can learn new tricks from time to time, and with the sophistication that our students bring to these tools, it is becoming easier and easier to bring technology into my lessons.

What technology tools do you use that keep on giving?

December 5, 2015

Using Technology to Grade Book Club Discussions

My school has taken the plunge into standards-based grading. Well, maybe I should say: my school has waded in up to its ankles into standards-based grading. We are grading and reporting on a small, manageable number of "categories" related to standards rather than each individual standard. For English Language Arts, we've chunked the standards into Reading, Writing, and Speaking & Listening (Language standards are incorporated under Reading and Writing). So far this semester I have given 3 Reading summative assessments, 1 Writing summative, and 0 Speaking & Listening assessments. 

Luckily, we are finishing our novel unit this week, which includes their third Book Club discussion. This seems like a perfect opportunity to grade Speaking & Listening standards! But without "fishbowling" six discussions (and taking 2 or 3 class periods to do so), how can I fairly assess each group? Getting around and listening to six discussions for 5-7 minutes each may not catch the normally quiet student who said all their "good stuff" while I was with another group. 

image from commons.wikimedia.com
Technology to the rescue! Students recorded their first two discussions using either QuickTime or Garage Band, and uploaded the audio file into a shared Google folder. Last year we tried using the Photo Booth app on their Macs, but the resulting video file was too large to upload. We discovered that audio files are smaller and easy to upload, and really it's the audio we want anyway. 

The first two discussions were formative. Students received the Book Club Discussion rubric before they began so they were aware of what would be assessed. As students discussed (and recorded), I walked around and spent a few minutes with about 4 groups. I coded the discussion so I could have a sense of how it was going: NT- New Topic, Add- Added to previous comment, TE- used Text Evidence, I- interruption, etc. 

If things seemed dire, I would interrupt and prompt the group; for example, "I've been sitting here for a few minutes, and I've already heard three new topics. See if you can stick with one discussion thread for longer so you can really dig deep into your ideas." Then I would listen for a few more minutes and see if they could make the correction. In all cases, before I left I would interrupt the discussion and give feedback to the group: "So here is what I heard while I was sitting here: 'A' started a new topic about ___, and then 'B' added on with some interpretation, and then 'C' brought in text evidence. This was a great way to keep the discussion going. I also noticed 'C' kept talking and never let 'D' have a chance. Make sure you are giving everyone equal air time. That's everyone's job to monitor. If you notice someone hasn't talked, be sure to invite them in. If you know you've already said a lot, hold your thought until others have a chance to speak. If you know you haven't said much, make sure your voice is heard-- you have important things to contribute!" When the discussion time was finished, the group rated themselves and others for the four categories of Prepared, Quality of Speaking, Quality of Listening, and Behavior. They then made a group goal for the next discussion. 

During the second discussion, they reviewed their goal, and repeated the process. I made sure I sat with the groups I hadn't seen the first round, and went back to those that had the most trouble previously. Again, groups recorded their discussion, rated themselves and others, and made a goal for their final one.

Now that students have had practice in recording (we had some tech issues to resolve the first time around), are familiar with the rubric because they used it for reflection and goal setting, and have gotten teacher and peer feedback, they should be ready for the final summative discussion. On Monday they will repeat the process just like they did the first two times. I will walk around, but I will not interrupt or give feedback this time. I want this to be independent, but I can also get info about body language, preparation (do they have their books and notebooks with them?), and behavior which the audio recordings may not pick up.  

Then I can sit down with their self-rated rubrics and listen to full discussions from the audio files. I will be able to catch the quiet kid who is reluctant to talk when I am sitting with the group. I can hear the "good stuff" come up and not just judge the bits and pieces I overhear for a few minutes. Technology allows me to be everywhere at once, which means I can grade each student fairly.

How do you grade Book Club discussions?


November 14, 2015

Re-visioning the Novel Unit for CCSS Implementation


We are implementing the Common Core Reading Standards this year, which has caused some major revision of units—and not just revision as in add a bit of this here and a bit of that there, but re-vision as in totally re-thinking how to approach our units. We rewrote our novel unit so that it shifted from a social justice theme inquiry to a fantasy genre focus. We are basing the fantasy unit on the Teacher’s College Grade 8 Reading Units of Study from 2011 (still hoping new reading units will come out for middle school this year).

There are some major shifts in our new unit because of the CCSS Reading standards, many more shifts than we had to make in our writing units last year. Here are a few that stand out and how we dealt with them.

R.8.2 Determine a theme or central idea of a text and analyze its development over the course of the text, including its relationship to the characters, setting, and plot; provide an objective summary of the text.
            We decided to keep the social justice thematic questions from the previous unit, because they work with fantasy as well: 
  • To what extent does power or the lack of power affect an individual? 
  • When should an individual stand up for what s/he believes in and what is the best way to do this? 
  • How do subtle issues of gender, race, class, and power function in society? 
These questions analyzing “power and resistance” became the theme to track. We introduced a new technology tool, Lucidcharts, as a way to track characters, setting, and plot across the book. Lucidcharts is part of the Google suite of applications, so the flowcharts and other graphic organizers that students develop can be shared with others in their Book Club. As the group moves through the book, they can collaboratively add on to their Charts and use them as talking points during their discussions.
R.8.5 Compare and contrast the structure of two or more texts and analyze how the differing structure of each text contributes to its meaning and style.
R.8.9 Analyze how a modern work of fiction draws on themes, patterns of events, or character types from myths, traditional stories, or religious works such as the Bible, including describing how the material is rendered new.

image from amazon.com
image from Gareth Hines wesbiste
            We are working with these two standards together. Fantasy novels, including science fiction dystopian stories, draw upon a long literary tradition. We are using a model text, The Last Book in the Universe by Rodman Philbrick, to introduce these ideas. This book has classic literary character types: hero, mentor, sidekick, damsel in distress, as well as structure: a quest. We will have students look for similar character types and plot structures in their books. The model text also draws upon The Odyssey for some of its plot events: people who escape into a dream world (Lotus Eaters), a character who is “blinded” in his one “eye” (Cyclops), a band of boys who act like animals (Circe’s Island), a gang of beautiful women who are merciless (the Furies), a journey via a Pipe that used to carry water (Odysseus’ journey across the sea).  Over the course of the unit, we will present other traditional stories, such as Hercules, and ask students to compare their stories to the characters and structures of the traditional ones. Rich discussions in Book Clubs will bring forth the analysis portions of these standards as students make connections between their book and the traditional tales.

R.8.7 Analyze the extent to which a filmed or live production of a story or drama stays faithful to or departs from the text or script, evaluating the choices made by the director or actors.
            This seems like a “stand-alone” standard to me, and I question why the authors of the CCSS deemed this important enough to include in its “top 10” reading standards. All of the other reading standards are applicable to a variety of texts and genres, and in multiple units and  lessons. I supposed it’s a nod to the importance of media literacy in the 21st century; however, it still seems like a “one off” lesson to me.  Nevertheless, it is a reading standard and so we must address it. While planning, I drew heavily upon Christy Rush-Levine's article on the Choice Literacy site, "Embracing Standards in Creative Ways."
movie produced by Learning Corporation of America, 1982
Since our novel unit uses a Book Club structure, we have six different books going, and not all of them have a film version. Neither does our model text, so we needed to approach this one a little differently (see—one-off!). We decided to linger with the model text we used in our recently completed Literary Essay unit: “All Summer in a Day” by Ray Bradbury. Fortunately, there was an old film version of the story made in the 1980s. It deviated quite a bit from the plot of the original story, including extending the ending, which shifted the theme. Before watching the film, we did a quick look at some of the “director’s choices” available while making a film. Using A Quick Guide for Beginners: Movie Aesthetics by StopMo Wiki, we went over some film-making moves like focus, frame, flux, and sound, and thought about how authors also try to use those same moves but with words. Next, students made a quick t-chart with Same and Different so they could take notes as they watched the movie. They also pulled out the story so it was in front of them.
As we watched the movie, I stopped at the end of the exposition--which was very different, and we discussed why the directed added so many school scenes and whether the essence of the story was still coming through.  I stopped at the climax, and we discussed how the addition of a character allowed for the main character to say all that “inner thinking” aloud. And at the end, I asked whether students felt the film version, which was very different than the written version, stayed true to the story and why.
It was a rich lesson, and fun for the students. And now I can “tick” it off my standards list.

The other five reading standards are also being addressed, but they didn't take too much shifting. Of course we are asking for text evidence to support their interpretations. Of course we are looking at author's craft and noticing things like allusions, irony, and suspense. Of course we are noticing how dialogue and plot events move the story forward. These are things that we addressed, maybe not to this level or specificity, in past reading units. But the four above took a lot of thinking and rewriting to incorporate into our novel unit. The unit is more rigorous because of these, and it is exciting to read fantasy with new eyes. 

Does anyone else think the text vs. film standard is a stand-alone standard? Are there good resources to draw on for explaining "themes, patterns of events, or character types" from traditional literature? I'm in new territory here, and any suggestions are welcome!

April 6, 2015

"Here's my project! Hope you like it :-)" Adjusting Tone to Fit Audience in Email Messages

CC image by Guudmorning via flickr
As a one-to-one laptop school, and as an ecologically-minded person, I find that I am using technology more and more in my classroom. Students do much more writing within Google docs or Word documents than with pencil on paper. For example, at the beginning of our last writing unit as we were generating poems, I gave students the option to have an online writer's notebook using a Google doc which they shared with me, or to use their paper notebook. In one class I had a 100% online notebook return, and in the other, it was over 80%. Grades and homework are posted online for students to access whenever they want. Students email me with projects attached or when they have questions. Students are very comfortable with technology, I am loving the ease of feedback, and we are all saving a lot of trees in the process. Lots of wins!

As a one-on-one laptop school, we spend a lot of time guiding students on making good choices while using technology. We have lessons on multitasking vs. "single tabbing", using time productively, evaluating the source of information, detecting bias, how to cite sources for information and images, and note-taking and paraphrasing to avoid plagiarism. But one thing we don't do in eighth grade is talk about writing emails.

A few days ago, during spring break, I received this email from a student:
"How come my grade didn't go up after the revolutionary war test even though it was sumitive [sic].

I got a 83 on my first test and a 93 on my second shouldn't my grade be like 89"
That was the whole thing. There was no subject in the subject box, no greeting or closing, no spell check or editing for mechanics or grammar.

CC image by CollegeDegrees360 via flickr
I was a bit taken aback by the tone of this email, although I'd gotten others like it throughout the years. I read it to my (non-teacher) friend who I was visiting at the time, and she was shocked at the rudeness. She suggested that I write back with an instructive or corrective message, something like "I will answer your question when you can address me with respect." That was certainly tempting.

Instead, I thought about what it was that bothered me about this email. Here's what I came up with:
  1. Tone: The student did not adjust his writing style to reflect his audience. The casual tone of this email reflects the way he talks to his friends, and is the kind of writing he does in a quick message. I am not his friend; I am his teacher. I expect a more formal tone.
  2. Structure: The lack of subject, greeting, and closing make this email feel aggressive and angry. When writing a letter, especially to someone in authority, it is customary to include formal structures and social niceties. 
  3. Care: This student obviously wrote this email in a hurry and sent it off. He did not take the time to edit or re-read before sending. This shows how little thought he put into the message, that he did not really care whether the message reflected the level of concern with which he intended it, and that he didn't consider that his reader deserves to read a well-edited message. 
  4. Misunderstanding: This student does not really understand how the grading system works. Yes, the two tests he is talking about are summative, and therefore go into the same category in the grading system (weighted 65% of the total grade). However, the first test was 83 points out of 100, and the second was 18.5 points out of 20. Since one has 5 times the number of points, it also has 5 times the weight on the grade. If I took 30 seconds to tell him this, he would probably say, "Oh, OK" and move on. However, if he actually looked at the grade book, he could figure this out himself. Instead of taking the time to do this, though, he would rather shoot a quick email to his teacher to get it sorted out.
The student is an eighth grade boy, a category of humans well known to be impulsive. He lives in a world where quick text messages and quick queries yield quick satisfactory answers. As a person, I know him to be a hard worker, a thoughtful friend, respectful of adults, and generally a nice boy. O don't think he intended to be rude; it just happened. So rather than sending a reprimand, I think I should view this as a little teachable moment for me.

I never established my expectations for how to address a teacher in an email at the beginning of the year. I never taught the required structure or tone. Although I give instructions like, "Use academic language" when blogging or during tests (and have explained what I mean by that phrase), I never applied that to email messages. If this is a battle I want to take on, I should approach it in a serious manner, teaching the conventions of email messages to adults just like I teach the conventions of essays or poetry. In the best case scenario, I should do this at the beginning of the year when all class routines are established. However, even now, I can teach it with an eye toward high school: "Your high school teachers will expect you to address them in a formal way when you write to them. It's important for you to practice this skill now so that it becomes a habit that will carry you through high school, onto college, and even into the workplace."

And I should also review how the grade book works, as well as how to see how the grades are calculated (there is a .pdf report option that shows how the grades work out). This will calm students down and help them see where the magical percentage number comes from.

In the fast pace of our lessons, I often get attachments without messages, or at most, "Here's my project. Hope you like it! :-)" I haven't worried about it in the past. I'm not going to go on an email rampage with my students now. However, it is a life lesson worth teaching, and obviously most students need to learn it, not just this one. And if I don't teach it, who will?

October 10, 2014

Investigative Journalism: an integrated Science/Social Studies/Language Arts Unit

As you know, dear reader, if you have been paying attention these last few months, we are implementing the CCSS writing standards in middle school this year. As part of the implementation, we bought the Units of Study for Argument, Informational, and Narrative Writing (Heinemann, 2014) developed by the staff at the Teacher's College Reading and Writing Project.
The grade 8 kit includes these three units: Unit 1: Investigative Journalism (Narrative), Unit 2: Literary Essay (Argument), and Unit 3: Position Papers (Informational). My teaching partner and I sat down with these units at the beginning of the year, and laid them out next to our existing units. Literary Essay-- check! A very close match. Position Papers-- We did a research-based argument essay, so we definitely see how a Position Paper would be an extension of that, so... check! Investigative Journalism-- ?? Our narrative writing unit was fantasy short stories, a really fun writing genre for eighth graders who had been writing realistic fiction short stories since third grade. We were reluctant to give it up, although Investigative Journalism did sound like an interesting unit. Hmmm... could we do both? If so, how?

Step in my Math/Science colleague. After returning from the NSTA conference last spring, he was very keen on doing an integrated Science/LA project this year. He suggested that Science could work on the content side of a project while LA could work on the writing side. Interesting suggestion... especially when he proposed doing it with the unit focusing on human impact on the environment and discovering solutions. All of a sudden, the geography theme of Human-Environment Interaction emerged from Social Studies. And how could we apply that to our Week Without Walls trip to Thailand, which we do a project with in SS anyway? I know you know where this is going...
Image of deforestation from Shutterstock via inhabitat website

So here we sit, my teaching partner and I, gazing at the Investigative Journalism unit, and with the integrated unit suggestion in my back pocket. Couldn't we have them write investigative science news articles that explained the human impact problem and the proposed solutions that they had already researched in Science, layered on an application piece of "What does this problem/solution look like in Thailand?" through more research in SS, and finally add in the field research piece of interviews, photos, and experiences while on our trip? They could write it all up using a journalistic style and publish the articles on an online science news magazine website that they would design (did I mention technology integration?). Voila!

Image of Asian elephants found on wikipedia
We are leaving out an important element of the original Investigative Journalism unit by teaching this way. The first "Bend" of the unit is about finding stories around you, living life like a journalist, noticing the everyday dramas that can turn into news stories. I understand the purpose behind this: helping kids lead a wide-awake life, keeping kids connected to the topic through choice and relevance, making it more authentic to what real journalists do. There is certainly value in that. Perhaps we can address a little part of that while we are on our trip, helping them see the connections between their experience and their news topic, helping them find the drama and personal angle to be highlighted within the story.

In any case, students will be exposed to a way to write information that is engaging, informative, and concise. Our job will be about teaching the writing skills (LA) and making a connection to another culture (SS). And we still get to do our fantasy short story writing unit (with a bit of revision to make sure we are lifting the level to meet the CCSS narrative writing standards)! Win, win!

September 20, 2014

Using Booksource's Classroom Organizer with My Classroom Library

Today I want to put a plug in for a great new tool I've started using with my classroom library: Booksource's Classroom Organizer. This is a free book check-out system that also generates handy teacher reports.

All set up and reports can be managed via the teacher page:


















The first thing to do to get things set up is to import your classroom inventory using an Excel spreadsheet. You can choose which categories to include for the books. It's easy to add additional titles individually once the big bulk of the inventory is imported.

Then you need to add students to your list so they have permission to check out (and check in) books electronically. They can do this from the student page:

Admittedly, the graphic is a bit elementary for eighth grade, but the tool is worth it. So far, students have been very responsible about using the system independently (once I posted all the login information in two or three places around the room). One super nice feature is that students will get an email every three weeks reminding them that they have a particular book checked out. This frees me up from looking at the hand-scrawled sign-out paper and trying to monitor that myself. Often just this little reminder is enough to get them to return the book to the library.



I haven't used the teacher reports much yet, since we've only been in school a month. Here are the options









This is my favorite report, Current Books Checked Out. This also gets sent to me automatically via email every three weeks so I can keep track.











This is what the Student Checkout Detail looks like for one prolific reader. I can see he is a dystopian reader mostly, but graphic novels also catch his attention.

I've been very pleased with the hand-off nature of the Classroom Organizer system. There is still an honor system in place for kids to actually do the check-in/check-out process instead of just walking out with a book. But it's no worse that it was before. The Classroom Org. system takes a little time to get set up, but their tech support people were super helpful when I ran into a glitch. For teachers who are trying to track students' reading lives, levels of text complexity, variety of genres, or volume, I highly recommend this system.

March 8, 2014

The Internet: Death of Personal Creativity or Learning Scaffold?

I have had a lot of conversations this week about plagiarism. They came on the heels of grading poetry reading anthologies; some students decided they needed some help interpreting poems, so they turned to the undisputed font of all wisdom-- the internet.

I believe they did this because they didn't trust their own interpretations. I had already seen the preparation work they had done, on paper, by themselves, with the poems. We had had conversations around their interpretations, and I had helped them tease out some of the more obscure or abstract lines. However, when they went to write up their notes into paragraphs describing meaning and musical devices, they got a little digital help (and didn't think about citing their source).

I am finding this to be a growing habit with my 8th graders. We became a 1:1 laptop school this year, so their devices are with them at all times in all classes. There are many advantages to this, and I am a big supporter of the change. But I do see behavior changing as a result.

It's not just this "borrowing" of ideas from others without crediting that I'm seeing. I've seen this before in previous years. My concern is the growing trend for my students to not trust their own thinking unless they get it confirmed by something on the internet.

Here's another recent example. In Social Studies, I put them in "Tavern Groups" during our Road to Revolution role play activity. I asked them to think of a name for their tavern and to draw a logo for their sign. I gave them a list of historical tavern names to choose from or to pattern their own original name. This part went well. When it was time to draw the logo, however, the laptop screens were flipped open.

"What are you doing? There weren't computers in 1765! What do you need your computer for?"
"I just need to see what an eagle (or a horse or a turtle) looks like!"

These children are 14 years old! They know what an eagle (or a horse or a turtle) looks like. However, they didn't trust that they could draw a familiar animal without seeing a digital image first (and no, they didn't ask if I had any animal books with pictures they could look at. If they had, I might have allowed it).

Is the internet the death of personal creativity and originality? Is creativity being re-defined as borrowing bits and pieces from other sources and putting them together into something new which is then claimed by the author as theirs? I see the .gifs on Tumblr or other sites that do just that. I watch the song or movie parodies on YouTube when my daughter shows me something she finds clever or witty. I have read the fan fiction she writes. None of these "new" products are completely original.

Or are these the scaffolds that budding artists and authors and thinkers need before they can launch their own original works? Certainly creating a piece based on a model is the foundation of the learning process in art and writing. Is it so bad that the model is an internet-based work?

At some point, however, we want our students to leave the models behind and find their own creative voices. That will take confidence and a spirit of risk-taking.

I guess my questions come down to these: How do we help our students break away from the scaffold so they can take that leap of faith into original works? and How can we ensure that they are ethical "borrowers" along the way?

February 15, 2014

Tech Integration: Enhancement or Interference?

A month ago, I sat down to look at the arc of the upcoming Poetry Reading unit. Because of some curriculum shifting, we had four full weeks for reading and analyzing poetry, as opposed to three in previous years. This is good, I thought, because it always seemed so rushed. This extra week will allow kids to really spend time digging into their poetry analysis and get their anthology projects done without stress.

Here I am with that fourth week ahead of me, and I'm thinking, "They need more time! They won't get their anthology project done in only five classes! I must extend the due date!"

What happened? First, there were the interruptions: one day for MAP testing, one day for a science field trip, one day for the visiting author workshop, one day for professional development... Oh, that's almost a whole school week.

Still... I'm only asking them to choose one poem and one song lyrics to analyze. I put in checkpoints along the way: after one week I want to see one poem you've chosen, after two weeks I want to see one poem with annotations and thematic thinking, after three weeks I want to see the second poem with annotations on meaning and music. Each checkpoint was a scramble. "I don't know what to choose!" "I can't find one I like!" "Oh, you want me to do margin notes?" "Can I give it to you tomorrow?"
image from Forbes website

I think back to how the poetry selection process was structured. My teaching partner and I are sharing a cart of poetry books from the library. We arranged English Language Arts and Social Studies classes so that they didn't overlap with our partner's; this way the cart can travel up and down the hallway for students to access in class. During the first week, the rule was: BOOKS ONLY! Although students were reluctant at first, the range of modern, thematic, classic, and familiar poetry in the books drew them in. Soon, sticky notes marking which poems they liked were decorating the edges of the books like fringe on cowboy chaps.

The second week marked the launch into lyrics, a new form of poetry for eighth grade. Such excitement (until they heard the "school appropriate language" rule)! At this point, vetted poetry websites like poetry.org and poemsandpoets.org, as well as a vetted song lyrics site, were opened up to the students. Boom! All eyes on screens. No hands touched the books. And no analysis happened until the checkpoint deadlines loomed (frantic scribbling minutes before the end of class!). 

So I have to wonder: Did the addition of technology enhance or interfere with the objectives of this unit?

image from engagementworx website
Did the enormous quantity of poems on the websites become overwhelming? Were the sites unusable for eighth graders who haven't yet formulated a list of favorite poets or poems? Were they randomly selecting and skimming, unable to settle into deep reading and thinking, distracted by the links and tabs and options available?

I think having them choose (clean) lyrics is part of the delay. They are so motivated and excited about this, however, that I don't want to change to a different form or restrict their choices (beyond the "school appropriate" rule). 

So how can we do this differently next year? I am a big believer in student choice, so I don't want to hand students five poems to analyze and turn in for a grade. On the other hand, maybe they have too much choice. The choice of poetry books on the cart seemed manageable. The choice of books, websites, and lyrics sites seems unmanageable. What if we chose 20 poems for students to choose from, and made them available as .pdfs in a shared Google Drive folder? Is that restricting them too much? 

If I keep lyrics as a new poetry form for eighth grade, and I want to, then perhaps I need to delay introducing it until after the second week. They could be thinking about it at home, but class time would be for reading poetry and practicing the strategies learned in minilessons for the first two weeks. Having a tight one-week choose-and-analyze deadline may circumvent the spinning wheels syndrome I'm seeing now.

There is a lot of great stuff happening during this Poetry Reading Unit. Kids are excited about poetry. They find poems that connect to their emotions and lives. They delight in discovering a symbol or a hidden musical device like assonance. They love digging deep into the meaning of a beloved song. They just need to spend less time skipping around and spend more time in the actual work of thinking. Four weeks flies by quickly!

January 18, 2014

Formative Feedback using Google Docs

We are in the thick of our new fantasy story writing unit. Students gathered lots of ideas launched from minilessons, chose one to commit to, and shared that idea with me using a plot mountain. They also identified a social issue that they are going to show through their story. As I reviewed plot mountains, I noticed how many stories mirrored their interests out of school: the video gamers have characters being sucked into games, the dystopian readers have futuristic settings with problems of injustice, boy-crazy girls have characters who fall in love with superheroes, and those concerned with bullying have bullying stories (one is being bullied by her talking diary who is revealing all her secrets!).

image from Google play website
After a week of drafting, it was time for me to take a close look at how these stories were going. The students are drafting on Google Docs, which they shared with me. Not only does it save paper, but it also allows me anytime access to their drafts and a tool for commenting easily. As I read, I made sure to find opportunities to highlight and write a positive comment in the margin where I saw the student apply something we talked about in class--slow motion details that show scenes clearly, an interesting lead, short tense sentences in an action scene, dialogue that reveals something about the character-- or something I really enjoyed as a reader-- a funny moment, a surprise, or an interesting conflict or character.

I also found opportunities to highlight and question places where I became confused as a reader. Perhaps the student shifted scenes abruptly and needed to transition more smoothly. Maybe the student started in first person and switched to third person halfway through (or vise-versa) or changed the character's name. Or something happened so abruptly that I was caught off-guard (What? Your best friend just entered your house and shot your brother out of the blue? Why?).

Other times I highlighted and nudged toward a skill taught during previous minilessons. For example, we've been focusing on sentence variety, so I might highlight a couple of simple sentences that could be combined, or long sentences in an action scene that might be better as short tense sentences, or fragments that seemed to have no purpose. Another common comment centered on a long "telling" lead paragraph, explaining everything about the fantasy setting or all about the character and their traits or conflict. For these, I usually said something like, "This is a long paragraph filled with lots of "telling". Consider how to "show" this information to the reader instead: you could say it during a conversation, you could have the character do something that shows his traits, or you could do... something else?"

Finally, I highlighted and "taught" some simple skills where I saw a consistent error. I highlighted dialogue and explained how to use punctuation inside the quotation marks when the quote is followed by a speech marker. I also told students to add a "return" and "tab" when each new person talks. Similarly, for those stories that were all one paragraph, I found the first place where the idea shifts, and "taught" how writers look for those places to add paragraph breaks (using a "return" and "tab" to indent). Several students shifted verb tense in the middle of their stories, so a quick "choose one tense and stick to it throughout your story" reminder at the point of shifting sufficed.

As I was doing all this reading, highlighting, and commenting, I had Lucy Calkins' voice in my head, "Teach the writer, not the writing." Although I felt I was fairly prescriptive in some places (especially the skills comments), I tried really hard to keep the ownership of the story in the students' hands. By asking questions, giving strategy reminders, and open suggestions starting with "consider", the choice about how to revise is up to the student.

I captured my suggestions on a document so that I can go back to the students and talk through some of the more difficult suggestions (such as the show-not-tell lead), and I can also go back to the story and see if my nudges moved the student along. Once students submit their final stories (they change ownership so that I am owner and they can only view), I can re-read my comments as I grade to see if they actually followed through on making changes.

Google docs keeps students' writing process very transparent. I have constant access to their work and students can always view my suggestions. Once they feel satisfied that they have acted on the suggestion, students have the power to "resolve" the comment, which hides it from the draft and makes it look clean, but it is still available to view through the comments button at the top of the page. Students can share their writing with a few others in order to get peer feedback, and I can see the kinds of comments their peers make. Are they the "I love your story! It's so good!" comment which does little to help the writer, or are they the constructive kind, either specific and positive ("I love how you showed that your character is brave by making her confront her fear of spiders") or helpful ("You need more periods here because I got confused when I read it")? Google docs has been a great tool to use for student writing projects!

July 1, 2013

CCSS New Writing Skills for Grade 8

Continuing my thinking about the CCSS Writing Standards and descriptors for my 8th grade writing program...

I read the section about the writing standards in Calkins, Ehrenworth, & Lehman's Pathways to the Common Core to get a better idea of what the standards say and their implications for implementation. One thing they suggested doing was looking horizontally across the descriptors to find out what new skills are required at each grade level. Since much of the wording is the same from grade to grade, it took a close look to find the new skills embedded in each descriptor. Once I did that, I found out the following new skills in the 8th grade writing descriptors (see bolded italics):

Argument Writing:
  • Introduce claim(s), acknowledge and distinguish the claim(s) from alternate or opposing claims
  • Use words, phrases, and clauses to create cohesion and clarify the relationships among claim(s), counterclaims, reasons, and evidence.
Informative/explanatory Writing:
  • organize ideas, concepts, and information into broader categories
  • develop the topic with relavant, well-chosen facts (etc.)
  • use appropriate and varied transitions to create cohesion
Narrative Writing:

  • Use narrative techniques, such as dialogue, pacing, description, and reflection to develop experiences (etc.)
  • Use a variety of transition words...to convey sequence...and show the relationships among experiences and events.
Use of technology:

  • Use technology... to publish writing and present the relationships between information and ideas efficiently

Most of these new skills make sense to me. For example, I already teach lessons about varied transitions, using "well-chosen" facts, and using transitions that signal the reader that the counterclaim is coming up. I understand how and why to teach reflection as part of narrative writing.

However, there are a few that are a bit unclear. What does "acknowledge and distinguish the claim from alternate or opposing claims" mean? Does that mean the claim and counterclaim are discussed in the introduction? Perhaps it means the kind of thesis that is worded: Some may think that ___ is ____; however, it really is _____ because of ____, ____, and ____.

Also, the technology skill is rather opaque. How can students publish writing using technology so that they "present the relationship between information and ideas efficiently"? What is the relationship between information and ideas? Isn't that what the topic sentences of the essay do? If so, why is this part of publishing with the technology standard?

Unfortunately, the CCSS exemplars are not very helpful. I am counting on Teacher's College to gather exemplars to help demonstrate some of these new skills. They already have performance assessments and anchor papers on a skills continuum for narrative, information, and opinion/argument writing, which are (going to be?) available for purchase through Heinemann. I hope these materials can help me and my colleagues see what the subtle differences are between grade 6, 7, and 8 writing pieces.